As one magazine is, so must the rest be. Please ignore this request, and others like it. Astounding Stories is different, unique; just keep it that way, and you will never lack a host of satisfied readers.

Before closing, I must voice my profound admiration for Murray Leinster's brilliant and engrossing story, "Murder Madness." It's the best serial you've printed so far; though I have high antic.i.p.ation for Arthur J. Burks' latest novel, "Earth, the Marauder."--Mortimer Weisinger, 3550 Rochambeau Ave., Bronx, New York.

_"I Mean Increased"_

Dear Editor:

I wish to thank you for your reply to my letter. I did not expect you to give me a personal reply: that was why I asked you to reply to me in "The Readers' Corner." You are the only editor I have ever known of that goes to the trouble to giving personal replies to readers. Other magazines require a nominal fee. That's another score for you!

Your personal letter, as a girl would aptly say, "tickled me all over."

I am sorry I can't get a subscription just yet, but I am "bound" to my newsdealer a little while yet, as I immediately gave him a monthly order for Astounding Stories.

If you are the one who picked the authors, you have the best taste I have ever seen in one person. But couldn't your taste be improved? Pardon me, I mean increased. Namely, please add to your taste: H. P. Lovecraft and Robert E.

Howard.

If you had different authors, in other words, new, inexperienced authors, I would object to your running more than one serial at a time, but with the marvelous old-timers I have no objections, for they can write long ones far better than they can the shorts. So keep them at work.

The three short stories, "Out of the Dreadful Depths," "The Cavern World" and "Giants of the Ray," were all very good.

Ray c.u.mmings was wonderful in the way he handled his "Brigands of the Moon." It was a "wow baby." "Murder Madness" is a great improvement over "Tanks." "Tanks" was the worst I've ever read by Leinster. But he came out of his reverie in "Murder Madness." It's great.

Sewell Peaslee Wright can work wonders with short stories.

Keep his "typer" clicking. By the way, may I say a few good words for Sophie Wenzel Ellis? If she can duplicate "Creatures of the Light," maker her repeat.

Victor Rousseau's story, "The Beetle Horde," kept me "all het up" throughout. "The Atom Smasher" was excellent. I also greatly like stories of the mighty Atlantis.

I agree with others of your readers that you should not let Astounding Stories be printed in such a small size. Make it a little larger, and give us smoother paper, and you will prosper greatly.

"The Moon Master" was excellent.--Gabriel Kirschner, Box 301, Temple, Texas.

_"Could Kick Myself"_

Dear Editor:

I have just started reading Astounding Stories and could kick myself for not seeing it sooner. In your latest issue, "The Moon Master," by Charles Diffin, is great. He sure knows how to write adventure with science.

I am a member of the Science Corresponding Club and am glad to say it. In later years the club will be known just like other big clubs of to-day, "Nationally and Sciencelly."--John Marcroft, 32 Washington St., Central Falls, R. I.

_A Full List_

In the January number of Astounding Stories c.u.mmings'

"Phantom of Reality" was the best, followed by Rousseau's "Beetle Horde."

February: 1--Diffin's "Sp.a.w.n of the Stars"; 2--Rousseau's "Beetle Horde"; 3--Ellis' "Creatures of the Light"; 4--Meek's "The Thief of Time."

March: 1--c.u.mmings' "Brigands of the Moon"; 2--Locke's "Vandals of the Stars"; 3--Meek's "Cold Light."

April: 1--c.u.mmings' "Brigands of the Moon"; 2--Burk's "Monsters of Moyen"; 3--Meek's "Ray of Madness"; 4--Pelcher's "Vampires of Venus."

May: 1--c.u.mmings' "Brigands of the Moon"; 2--Leinster's "Murder Madness"; 3--Rousseau's "Atom Smasher."

June: 1--c.u.mmings' "Brigands of the Moon"; 2--Leinster's "Murder Madness"; 3--Diffin's "Moon Master."

Please give us a story by H. P. Lovecraft, if you can get one.--Carl Ballard, 202 N. Main St., Danville, Va.

_"Words Cannot Express"_

Dear Editor:

I have read your wonderful magazine since it was first published, and words cannot express what a fine magazine I think it is. All my life, I have hoped that someone would publish a magazine just like Astounding Stories. A magazine just full to the brim with the right kind of stories; thrilling stories of super-science, well written in plain and convincing English by wide awake authors.

I thought that "The Cavern World" was a whiz of a story, and "The Moon Master" was so exciting that I sat up late at night reading it. Let's have more of that kind of science story, that thrills every red-blooded American.

I hope that you print your magazine on better paper.--David Bangs, 190 Marlboro St., Boston, Ma.s.s.

_Unconvinced_

Dear Editor:

I received the latest issue of Astounding Stories, and in looking it through I noticed your comments on reprints. Your argument can easily be shot full of holes, and that's what I intend to do.

First: Those stories being printed now are far inferior to the reprints. Even your best stories, such as "Murder Madness" and "Brigands of the Moon," cannot be compared with such stories as "Station X," "The Moon Pool," "The Metal Monster," or "The Columbus of s.p.a.ce" and "The Second Deluge."

Second: The Sat.u.r.day Evening Post cannot be compared with our magazine, for all the stories printed in it can be obtained in book form, while the scientific novels are almost all out of print.

Third: There is surely more than one out of a hundred who haven't read the reprints. Just because some have read them is no reason that they don't want them. I know, for I have a large library of reprints and have read, and own, almost every one of them, yet I would gladly see them again.

Fourth: The authors need not starve. You could easily devote just a small s.p.a.ce for reprints, and many would pay twenty-five cents for the magazine.

The fairest and most American idea would be to let your readers vote for this. Here is vote No. 1 for reprints.--Woodrow Gelman, 1603 President St., Brooklyn, N. Y.

_Praise and Suggestions_

Dear Editor:

I have just finished the July issue of Astounding Stories and cla.s.sify the stories as follows:

"Beyond the Heaviside Layer," good; "Earth, the Marauder,"

excellent, best in issue; "From an Amber Block," fairly good; "The Terror of Air-Level Six," very good; "The Forgotten Planet," excellent; "The Power and the Glory,"

good; "Murder Madness," very good, but not so much so as preceding chapters.

Now for a few criticisms: